Learning from severe maladministration – December 2025
Taking the key lessons from our severe maladministration decisions.
About this report
This report focuses on repairs, just over 6 months since we released our Spotlight report on repairs and maintenance.
These complaints involve a wide range of repairs from faulty doors, windows, and roofs to kitchens and bathrooms.
With Awaab’s Law, there is a greater focus on connecting the household’s circumstances to the condition of the property. This will make for more person-focused repairs services.
Domestic abuse
Domestic abuse survivors may rely on social housing to provide security and safety following a traumatic experience. Repairs, especially for work that relates to security, may need to be treated with urgency and care.
If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic abuse, there is help to support you. You can call the National Domestic Abuse Helpline for free 24/7: 0808 2000 247.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to domestic abuse:
- A2Dominion 202427132
- Orbit Group 202411340
Learning from domestic abuse
It’s vital that landlords recognise and adapt service delivery based on the individual circumstances of the household. Domestic abuse survivors may require urgent repairs to security features to feel safe in their homes.
Landlords should consider how it records and acts on information from a household. This helps make informed decisions about prioritisation and urgency. It can also be key to deciding whether there’s need for mitigating measures or even a temporary move.
Repairs, such as a faulty entrance door, can be the highest priority for a domestic abuse survivor. Proactive and empathetic communication should also be central to responses. It also ensures that landlords are keeping correct records about the household circumstances up to date.
We understand that dealing with domestic abuse and survivors may be challenging for social housing staff. There are plenty of organisations that provide training and support:
- Addressing Domestic Abuse
- Standing Together Domestic
- Abuse Housing Alliance
Children
When deciding which property condition case to deal with first, landlords should assess the circumstances of each household. This may mean faster repairs, quicker temporary moves, or more caring approaches. Where children are involved, this can be even more important.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to children:
- London Borough of Lambeth 202428007
- Birmingham City Council 202420180*
- Notting Hill Genesis 202344083
Learning from children
When a child is present in the home, it can significantly change the response that a landlord needs to provide. This may mean that safety is more of an issue, or the impact of delaying repairs worsened.
Landlords should consider doing an early risk assessment. Or keeping risk assessments up to date as the repair develops. Landlords should keep in regular contact with the household. This will ensure it has a firm understanding of how the issue is impacting any children.
It may also mean that landlords need to consider temporarily moving residents earlier or at a time they would not usually. However, there are different aspects landlords should consider as part of this. For example, how close the home is to schools or family who can help with childcare.
Accessible housing
Getting adaptations or repairs right where a disability is present can be a complex area of repair for landlords. Making homes accessible for those that live in them is a vital part of social housing. This is why, in our Spotlight report on attitudes, respect, and rights, we say that “general needs does not mean no needs”.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to accessible housing:
- Freebridge Community Housing 202422538
- Basildon Council 202447527
- Birmingham City Council 202404739
Learning from accessible housing
Repairs that make a home more accessible or involve adaptations can be complex. Clear and proactive communication with the resident must be at the heart of this work.
Landlords should carry out risk assessments early and follow any advice from Occupational Therapists.
Repairs can seriously affect someone living with a disability. Landlords should decide if they need to arrange a temporary move. As this may change as the works develop, this should be kept under review.
Adaptations and repairs to make a home accessible can be complex. Tell residents what’s happening at each step.
Where we have seen good practice in this area, landlords have appointed a single point of contact.
Roof repairs
Roof repairs can be complex and take a long time. This means landlords need to manage many aspects correctly throughout the repair.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to roof repairs:
- L&Q 202426266)
- Harlow Council 202432277
Learning from roof repairs
Roof replacements are often major in nature and the process of agreeing the scope of works can be lengthy. Good proactive communication with a resident is key to the success of any repair in this area. Strong records also help to avoid too many repeat inspections.
As replacements can take a while, landlords should consider temporary fixes or moves early. Consider this along with a household risk assessment. Use both to set the right priority for actions.
Windows and doors
We have raised windows as an emerging issue over the past year, with health and safety issues being present where we see failure. We also see issues with doors, as evidenced by some of the earlier decisions in this report regarding domestic abuse.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to windows and doors:
- Moat Homes 202444922*
- Hyde Housing Association 202429476
- L&Q 202234897*
- Newlon Housing Trust 202324954*
Learning from windows and doors
We have set out a range of key learning in our reports, specifically on windows. This includes landlords ensuring they promptly inspect homes when residents report window safety concerns. This inspection can assess whether landlords need to replace or repair windows. It can also look at the impact on the household. This should then inform how the landlord proceeds with the case.
We acknowledge that window replacement can take time. This is especially true in high rise blocks. Therefore, landlords should consider what temporary fixes they can put in place to reduce the risks while they schedule those works. This may include preparing a temporary move for the household.
Some of this learning is also true for doors, where replacements are not always simple.
Sometimes major works suit a job better than one-off fixes. We understand that many things can change work timescales. This includes contractor availability, and the scope of works that landlords require.
However, the risk to the resident's safety should be a priority and landlords should adequately assess this.
Landlords should assess how timely future works will be before deciding not to replace windows and doors outside of this schedule. They should assess how likely these works are to happen on time. They should also evaluate the seriousness of the issues and household circumstances, along with any expert advice received.
If landlords decide to replace windows or doors as part of major works, this can take time. They should consider what temporary repairs they can do in the meantime.
Landlords should provide timescales for future works. They should also regularly communicate throughout. It keeps residents informed, especially if there are delays or changes.
There are also lessons in these cases for landlords managing other tenures such as shared ownership or leasehold. It’s important the landlord is sure in its responsibilities and whether they need to conduct section 20 consultations.
Homeownership
Complaints involving leaseholders or shared owners can need a different approach. Landlords may need to consider different factors depending on what the repair requires.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to homeownership:
- A2Dominion 202342027
Learning from homeownership
Landlords should maintain and repair the structure and exterior of properties, as most leases state.
Most repair policies say landlords do not need to repair internal damage to leasehold properties. The exception is when a fault in the building's structure causes the damage.
Some repairs can be complex, and landlords can find it challenging to treat leaseholders fairly in these situations. Early communication and effective record-keeping are central to a strong response.
We’ve set out other failures in previous reports. This includes delays to inspections and not progressing repairs. These failures affect leaseholders as much as any other resident.
Landlords should also know what enforcement action it can take. When landlords reach the thresholds for enforcement action, it should take it. The purpose is to keep all residents safe. This includes using injunctions and taking legal action.
Access
Gaining access to a resident’s home mostly goes smoothly for landlords. However, it was a key theme from our recent Spotlight report on repairs and maintenance where landlords needed to improve.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to access:
- A2Dominion 202415320*
Learning from access
When making appointments landlords should give sufficient notice to the resident and try to accommodate their preferred timings.
Landlords should also consider confirming appointments. This could include sending reminders by text message or other contact method agreed with residents.
Landlords could also update the resident at the earliest opportunity if there is a need to reschedule. We provide recommendations about the impact of missed appointments in our Spotlight report on knowledge and information management.
Landlords should make sure contractors or operatives understand what work they need to do. They should also explain any specific requirements.
This will reduce the number of missed appointments.
Failings within internal complaints procedures
The complaints procedure is an opportunity to recover any service failings. However, these cases show landlords compounding failures in its service areas during the internal complaints procedure.
Cases highlighted in the full report relating to internal procedures:
- London Borough of Lewisham 202337288*
- London Borough of Haringey 202307195
Learning from internal complaints procedures
A landlord’s internal complaints procedure plays an important role in resolving an issue for a resident. It is also an opportunity for the landlord to learn. While there are important timescales involved through our Complaint Handling Code, key is ensuring that responses are ethical too.
This means providing genuine apologies, demonstrating learning, and setting out clear timeframes for resolving issues.
Accurate records are key for landlords, being able to rely on this evidence means landlords can make informed complaint responses. This also means a resident can be confident in the landlord’s approach and improve relationships.
Learning from severe maladministration report
Download the full learning from severe maladministration report to see the case studies in more detail.
Learning from severe maladministration report (PDF)
* We anonymise all decisions, so residents’ names are not used, but landlords are named. In some cases, we may decide not to publish a decision if it is not in the resident’s or landlord’s interest, or the resident’s anonymity may be compromised.
Centre for Learning resources
Repairs
Complaints about repairs and property condition are the most common topic that we see in our casework.
Explore our reports, case studies and guidance to gain an understanding of how to navigate repair concerns.
Knowledge and Information Management (KIM)
Effective Knowledge and Information Management (KIM) is a challenging issue for landlords.
Discover guidance, spotlight reports, and training options to help you understand this key topic.
Window-related complaints
This key topic page explores the Ombudsman’s open letter to landlords raising concerns about the handling of window-related complaints in the sector:
Find out more about window-related complaints, and the expectations the Ombudsman has set ahead of its coming report.
Temporary moves
This key topic page shares learning from cases involving moving residents to alternative accommodation, either temporarily or permanently, due to significant repairs or their home being unfit for habitation, known as ‘decants’ by the social housing sector.
Hazards
Explore our casework on health and safety hazards in social housing.
These include damp, mould, excess cold, and fire risks. Find out what landlords can do to improve safety and learn from complaints.
Damp and mould
Damp and mould is a reoccurring issue that continually arises in our case work.
Residents and landlords can use this page to find out more about this key topic including guidance, spotlight reports, and training options for landlords.
Attitudes, respect, and rights
Poor communication is often the root cause of housing complaints, eroding trust and leading to escalating issues.
Discover guidance, spotlight reports, and training options to help you understand this key topic.